Pastoral Staff


Pastor Drew Toucher - Senior Pastor

PD antique

Pastor Drew Toucher became Fleetwood Bible Church’s 22nd Senior Pastor after 8 years as Pastor of Student Ministries at FBC. PD served a total of 21 years in youth ministry in PA & New Jersey before this transition (officially) on August 2 2020.

Pastor Drew holds a degree in Christian Ministry received from Messiah College in Grantham, PA, where he also met his wife, Julie. The Touchers have two daughters, Kelsie and Sophie and two cats. Pastor Drew loves the New York Mets and New York Giants and he shares his love of sports with youth in the Fleetwood community coaching soccer, track, and basketball.

In his spare time, PD enjoys watching sports, hiking with his family and reading, citing Tim Keller as a favorite preacher and author. An experienced guitar player himself, Pastor Drew also enjoys the music of Elevation Worship and Caedmon’s Call.

While serving in youth ministry, his mission was to partner with families to "raise up a generation of radical God-followers who will make a big fat dent on this earth for the glory of Jesus Christ." His current mission is similar and extends past the youth ministry to “transform lives that transform the world.” 

Pastor Drew is available at

Pastor Nathanael A. Naugle - Executive Pastor

PN antique

Pastor Nathanael has been an active member of Fleetwood Bible Church since June of 1999. Entering vocational ministry more than a decade ago, he has had years to utilize his love for people as Associate Pastor for Family Care joining FBC’s staff in November of 2007. His current role as Executive Pastor (since 2017) finds him in the position to oversee the general operations of the church. PN serves in various ministries and occasionally can be found behind the pulpit. Though he admits, he’d rather be getting to know people better personally, ideally over a meal!

After graduating from High Point Baptist Academy, Pastor Nathanael received a degree in Bible from Lancaster Bible College in Lancaster, PA. He married his wife, Sonya, and, after working several years in the carpentry industry, received his call to serve at Fleetwood Bible Church. The Naugles live on their family farm with three of their four children. PN has two grandchildren, who he adores and promises to spoil when his oldest daughter isn't looking. When he is not counseling or visiting (or spoiling grandkids), Pastor Nathanael is usually riding a tractor or fixing something, or he’s crashing the Golden Sisters luncheons!

Pastor Nathanael is a fan of many things including C.S. Lewis, Dr. David Jeremiah, Alistair Begg, grandchildren, working with his hands and big juicy hamburgers!  PN’s favorite verse can be found in II Cor. 4:7 "But we have this treasure in jars of clay, to show that the surpassing power belongs to God and not to us." His true passion is to see people experience God's unconditional love and claim the true joy that is found only in Him.

Pastor Nathanael continues to counsel and leads the Wednesday morning men’s bible study. He can be reached at