Pastoral Staff

Pastor Randy Johnson - Senior Pastor

Randy & Susan Website Pic.JPGRandy Johnson joined the pastoral team of FBC as Senior Pastor in March, 2018.  His greatest desire is to live a “sent” life by exemplifying the love of Jesus to everyone whose path God allows him to cross – whether it is in the church, the community, or beyond.  Some of the responsibilities his ministry at FBC include are:  weekly preparation of life applicable teaching from God’s Word as well as counseling and visitation.

Pastor Randy was born and raised outside of Dallas, TX in Mesquite.  Before coming to PA, he achieved his undergraduate degree from Wayland Baptist University, pastored a church bi-vocationally and then another full time.  He and his family then moved to Kentucky where he pastored full time while completing his MDiv from the Billy Graham School of Evangelism, Missions, and Church Growth at The Southern Seminary in Louisville.  In 1999, he moved to the suburbs of Philadelphia where he planted NorthPointe Community Church and served as Lead Pastor for 19 years.

Pastor Randy and Susan, his wife of 38 years, live in Fleetwood.  They have been blessed with 2 amazing children, 2 wonderful kids-in-law and 6 incredible grandchildren who “fill the hole they never knew they had.” They are fortunate to have their children and grandchildren within just a couple of hours away.

A few activities Pastor Randy enjoys outside of church are working in the yard, relaxing at the beach, and dreaming of riding a Harley once again.


Pastor Nathanael A. Naugle - Executive Pastor

PN antiquePastor Nathanael has been an active member of Fleetwood Bible Church since June of 1999. He has utilized his love for people and the Word of God to counsel, visit, mentor, and teach Sunday School classes at many levels. He has held various Ministry Council positions and has been in charge of the Deacon Family Care ministry since January 2007.

His passion is to see people experience God's unconditional love and claim the true joy that is found only in Him. Pastor Nathanael has been serving as the Associate Pastor for Family Care since November of 2007 when he accepted the call by God and the Elders of Fleetwood Bible Church. His ministry constitutes counseling, visitation, ministry mobilization, and general family care.

After graduating from High Point Baptist Academy, Pastor Nathanael received a degree in Bible from Lancaster Bible College in Lancaster, PA. He married his wife, Sonya, and, after working several years in the carpentry industry, received his call to serve at Fleetwood Bible Church. The Naugles live on their family farm with three of their four children. PN has one grandson, Alton, who he adores and promises to spoil when his oldest daughter isn't looking. When he is not counseling or visiting (or spoiling Alton), Pastor Nathanael is usually riding a tractor or building something with attention to the finest detail. 



Pastor Drew Toucher - Pastor for Student Life Ministries

PD antiquePastor Drew began serving at Fleetwood Bible Church in August of 2012. His mission is to partner with families to raise up a generation of radical God-followers who will make a big fat dent on this earth for the glory of Jesus Christ.

His greatest joy in ministry is celebrating the graduation of high school seniors who have made personal commitments to Jesus Christ and have built a strong foundation of faith that will last them a lifetime. Pastor Drew loves the New York Mets and New York Giants. 

Prior to joining FBC, Pastor Drew received a degree in Christian Ministry from Messiah College in Grantham, PA and shortly after marrying his wife Julie, he served as a youth pastor in several different churches. 

Pastor Drew and Julie have two beautiful daughters, Kelsie and Sophie. You can usually find Pastor Drew (or his alter ego, Bobby Montgomery) running or playing his guitar with the occasional shout of “Pee-yah!”