Pastors & Staff

Pastor Drew Toucher

Senior Pastor

Pastor Drew Toucher became Fleetwood Bible Church’s 22nd Senior Pastor after 8 years as Pastor of Student Ministries at FBC. PD served a total of 21 years in youth ministry in PA & New Jersey before this transition (officially) on August 2, 2020.
Pastor Drew holds a degree in Christian Ministry received from Messiah College in Grantham, PA, where he also met his wife, Julie. The Touchers have two daughters, Kelsie and Sophie and two cats. Pastor Drew loves the New York Mets and New York Giants and he shares his love of sports with youth in the Fleetwood community, coaching soccer, track, and basketball.
In his spare time, PD enjoys watching sports, hiking with his family and reading, citing Tim Keller as a favorite preacher and author. An experienced guitar player himself, Pastor Drew also enjoys the music of Elevation Worship and Caedmon’s Call.
While serving in youth ministry, his mission was to partner with families to "raise up a generation of radical God-followers who will make a big fat dent on this earth for the glory of Jesus Christ." His current mission is similar and extends past the youth to “transform lives that transform the world.” 

Pastor Nathanael Naugle

Executive Pastor

Pastor Nathanael has been an active member of Fleetwood Bible Church since June of 1999. Entering vocational ministry more than a decade ago, he has had years to utilize his love for people as Associate Pastor for Family Care joining FBC’s staff in November of 2007. His current role as Executive Pastor (since 2017) finds him in the position to oversee the general operations of the church. PN serves in various ministries and occasionally can be found behind the pulpit. Though he admits, he’d rather be getting to know people better personally, ideally over a meal!
After graduating from High Point Baptist Academy, Pastor Nathanael received a degree in Bible from Lancaster Bible College in Lancaster, PA. He married his wife, Sonya, and, after working several years in the carpentry industry, received his call to serve at Fleetwood Bible Church. The Naugles live on their family farm with three of their four children. PN has two grandchildren, who he adores and promises to spoil when his oldest daughter isn't looking. When he is not counseling or visiting (or spoiling grandkids), Pastor Nathanael is usually riding a tractor or fixing something, or he’s crashing the Golden Sister's luncheons!
Pastor Nathanael is a fan of many things including C.S. Lewis, Dr. David Jeremiah, Alistair Begg, grandchildren, working with his hands and big juicy hamburgers!  PN’s favorite verse can be found in II Cor. 4:7 "But we have this treasure in jars of clay, to show that the surpassing power belongs to God and not to us." His true passion is to see people experience God's unconditional love and claim the true joy that is found only in Him.

Pastor Marcos Crespo

Pastor of Next Generation Ministries

A fan of spicy food, video games and all types of music, Pastor Marcos Crespo is physically unable to take a serious picture. (His wife, Mary can verify that!) Young, energetic & quirky, Pastor Marcos practices keeping up with the youth he mentors by playing with his own kids, Micah and Monica, which is one of his favorite pastimes.
Boricua and bilingual, PM was born in Camuy, Puerto Rico (although he dislikes the beach and sand!) and has lived in Chicago and southeastern PA for the last 17 years where he served with his wife Mary as a youth pastor for 6 years, all while teaching High School!
Pastor Marcos holds a B.S. In Psychology and a minor in Religious Studies from Ursinus. He also completed the Pastoral Leadership Institute (PLI) of the Missionary Church. PM enjoys reading the works of Leonard Ravenhill and Esau McCaulley and his favorite verse can be found in Micah 6:8, "He has shown you, O mortal what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly, love mercy and walk humbly with your God." Pastor Marcos is passionate about our youth to have “an unshakeable identity in Jesus Christ….where he is the center of that person’s life.”
We are excited to welcome Pastor Marcos to our pastoral staff in February 2021 as Pastor of Next Generation Ministries! 

Eli Werley

Pastoral Intern

Eli's serves at FBC as the Pastoral Intern with his primary responsibility being oversight of the youth group. He has been serving in this capacity since August of 2020 in conjunction with Lancaster Bible College's internship program. Eli's family, which includes his mother Melissa, father Matt, and younger sister Ava have gone to FBC for 17 years. Eli is a huge basketball and football fan, following the Philidelphia 76ers (Trust The Process) and Green Bay Packers due to his father's Wisconsin roots. Despite the amazing taste in sports teams, the taste for vegetables has yet to resonate with Eli, much to his mother's chagrin. Overall, Eli is looking forward to learning more and more about ministry throughout his internship and is also very excited to serve as a camp counselor with Student Life Camp this summer 2021.

Heidi Foreman

Communication Director

Heidi Foreman joined the FBC staff in January 2017. In her role as CD Heidi combines components of Creativity, Coordination, Communication and Connection. She's pretty much involved in everything except preaching! She serves the FBC body in support of the pastoral staff and ministry directors and holds leadership oversight for social media, marketing and FBC's website. Heidi has a passion for creative arts and seeks to incorporate these gifts in different ways throughout the church to the glory of God.

Heidi is married to her high school sweetheart, Bill and they have four children. Her favorite past times are "making things pretty", pottery and the beach. 

Diane Reed

Office Secretary

Diane Reed has been the FBC Church Secretary since 2006 and serves the people of FBC, pastors and staff with a variety of needs. She handles the clerical demands of her job expertly. Married to John Reed, former Pastor of Evangelism at FBC, the couple has two children and three grandchildren (Griffin, Reed and Elliot.) Diane loves walking, the number 5, the color blue, mint tea, chocolate and ice cream and has lived in several states and over 20 different homes in her lifetime. She is a great listener and always accommodating. Diane is allergic to disorganization, though. :-) She says that she "loves the variety of her job" and is always willing to assist anyone who comes into or contacts the church with whatever they need. 

Eileen Kistler

Office Manager & Volunteer Coordinator

Eileen Kistler has worked at FBC the longest of all of the staff members. As Office Manager, Eileen oversees the general workings of the office including volunteer placement and scheduling. Eileen is married to Elder Ken Kistler and they have a married daughter and several "adopted" grandchildren. Eileen cares for her father who lives with them and and generally works remotely from home so that she is available for him. 

Amy Gambler

Church Treasurer

Amy Gambler our Financial Treasurer and mother of two teenage boys. Has her hands full! Amy is not shy to a challenge, though. A multiple triathlon participant ( and married for all but 25 years to Elder Matt Gambler,) Amy tackles the "books"; pays the bills, does the payroll and the church budget process and that's just her day job! She loves all types of outdoor adventure and loves to travel the world doing it. Amy claims to be one of God's greatest miracles having ben adopted and aimed in not so great directions, she is redeemed and renewed to know her worth and live for Him. This is what makes her so sensitive to the underdog. Speaking of dogs, Amy has two. Malcolm and Abby. Ask her about them sometime!

Bev Hummel

Financial Secretary & World Outreach Coordinator

Bev Hummel is FBC's Financial Secretary. Serving the body of FBC for the last 7 years, Bev is our "bean counter" handling the tithes & offerings, online payments and other money requirements for the ministries of the church. Bev is married to Jeff Hummel and unlike her husband, is averse to public speaking. She would prefer to take quiet walks and spend time with her family of two children and one grandchild. Bev and Jeff are also the World Outreach Ministry Directors and spend much time keeping us connected to all our missionaries. Ask Bev about her favorite ice cream flavor, she's a fan!